Menu
Shopping Cart

No products in de cart.

2 Materials: Polycarbonate Helmets vs. Fiberglass Helmets: Which Material Protects You Best?

Discover de advantages en disadvantages of polycarbonate en fiberglass helmets. Learn which material de provides the best protection for your safety en comfort while cycling.
Comparison of polycarbonate en fiberglass helmets: protection, weight en comfort.

Introduction

If you're looking for a new helmet, you soon find yourself faced with an important choice: polycarbonate or fiberglass? These two materials form de the basis of de most modern helmets, but what exactly are they en why is de choosing between them so crucial to your safety?

What are polycarbonate en fiberglass?

Polycarbonate is a thermoplastic polymer known for its strength en toughness. In helmets, it is used because of its ability to absorb impact en distribute. Fiberglass, on the other hand, is a composite material composed of thin glass fibers embedded in a resin matrix. It is known for its high strength-to-weight ratio.

Importance for de safety of motorcyclists

De choosing between polycarbonate en fiberglass is more than a matter of personal preference. It directly affects your safety on de road. Both materials offer excellent protection, but they do so in different ways:

  • Polycarbonate helmets are generally more flexible en can withstand multiple impacts better.
  • Fiberglass helmets are stiffer en can better absorb a single, heavy impact.

Understanding these properties is essential to making an informed choice that fits your riding style en needs. In de following sections, we dive deeper into de specific advantages en disadvantages of both materials so you can make de best decision for your safety on de road.

De basic principles of helmet materials

To choose de right helmet, it is essential to understand de basics of helmet materials. Let's look at de properties of polycarbonate en fiberglass, de two most commonly used materials in modern helmets.

Properties of polycarbonate

Polycarbonate helmets are known for their strength en flexibility. This material can deform upon impact en then returns to its original shape. This property makes polycarbonate helmets particularly suitable for absorbing multiple light impacts.

Another advantage of polycarbonate is de cost-effectiveness. The manufacturing process is relatively inexpensive, resulting in affordable helmets without sacrificing safety. This makes polycarbonate a popular choice for novice riders or those looking for a budget-friendly option.

Characteristics of fiberglass

Fiberglass helmets are distinguished by their lightweight nature en durability. They are often lighter than their polycarbonate counterparts, which can improve comfort during long rides. In addition, fiberglass helmets tend to last longer if properly maintained.

One of de most notable properties of fiberglass is de superior impact absorption. In the event of a severe impact, the material de disperses energy over a larger surface area, reducing de risk of serious injury. This makes fiberglass helmets particularly suitable for high-speed riders or people who often travel long distances.

Both materials have their own strengths en it is important to consider your riding style en needs when choosing a helmet. Whether you choose polycarbonate or fiberglass, make sure de helmet meets de applicable safety standards for optimal protection.

Crash test dummy wearing a helmet in a laboratory setting, surrounded by safety testing equipment

Safety aspects of polycarbonate helmets

Polycarbonate helmets offer a number of important safety benefits that make them a popular choice among motorcyclists. Let's take a look at de specific aspects that contribute to their protective properties.

Shock absorption en energy distribution

One of de most striking features of polycarbonate helmets is their ability to absorb impact en de impact energy efficiently. Upon impact, the polycarbonate material deforms slightly, spreading de force of de impact over a larger surface area. This significantly reduces de risk of serious head injury.

Resistance to penetration

Polycarbonate is known for its high resistance to penetration. This means that sharp objects or debris are less likely to penetrate de helmet shell. This property is crucial for protecting de rider from potentially life-threatening injuries in accidents.

Sustainability in repeated impacts

Another advantage of polycarbonate helmets is their ability to withstand multiple light impacts without losing their protective properties. This makes them particularly suitable for daily use or for riders who experience more frequent minor falls or collisions.

It is important to remember that regardless of the material, a helmet must always meet de applicable safety standards. Regular inspection en replacement after an accident or after de by de manufacturer recommended hours of use remain essential for optimal protection.

Safety benefits of fiberglass helmets

Fiberglass helmets offer a number of unique safety benefits that make them a popular choice among experienced motorcyclists. Let's take a look at de specific aspects that contribute to their superior protection.

Superior impact protection

Fiberglass helmets are known for their excellent ability to absorb heavy impacts. In an impact, the material de disperses energy over a larger area, significantly reducing de force applied to the head. This can make the difference between minor en serious injury in an accident.

Improved energy dissipation

De unique structure of fiberglass provides efficient energy dissipation. When de helmet takes a hit, de glass fibers de disperse impact across the entire surface of de helmet. This reduces de chance of focal pressure points that can lead to serious brain injury.

Long-term structural integrity

Fiberglass helmets retain their structural integrity after an impact better than many other materials. This means they retain their protective properties longer, even after smaller impacts or falls. For riders who often travel long distances or ride in challenging conditions, this can be a crucial feature.

These safety benefits make fiberglass helmets an excellent choice for motorcyclists who prioritize maximum protection. However, it is important to remember that de best helmet is always the one that fits well en meets de applicable safety standards.

Person carefully examining and comparing the interior padding of two different helmet types in a store display

Comfort en fit

When it comes to comfort en fit, both polycarbonate and fiberglass helmets play an important role. Let's look at de differences between these materials en how they can affect your riding experience.

Weight differences

Fiberglass helmets typically prevail de when it comes to weight. They are often lighter than their polycarbonate counterparts, which is especially noticeable during longer rides. A lighter helmet can de significantly reduce fatigue in your neck en shoulders, allowing you to ride comfortably for longer.

Impact on neck strain en driving comfort

The lower weight of fiberglass helmets translates directly to less strain on your neck. This can be especially beneficial for riders who suffer from neck pain or those who often ride long distances. Polycarbonate helmets, while slightly heavier, often offer a good balance of weight en protection.

Ventilation aspects

In terms of ventilation, both materials perform well, provided de helmet is properly designed. However, fiberglass allows itself to be formed into more complex shapes more easily, which can result in helmets with a more sophisticated ventilation system. This can provide a cooler en drier climate inside de helmet, significantly increasing comfort during hot days.

Regardless of the material, it is crucial to choose a helmet that fits your head shape well. A well-fitting helmet, whether made of polycarbonate or fiberglass, will always be more comfortable than an ill-fitting helmet of any material.

Durability en lifetime

When it comes to de durability en longevity of helmets, both polycarbonate and fiberglass play an important role. Let's look at de different aspects that affect de longevity of these materials.

Resistance to UV radiation en weather influences

Both materials offer good protection from UV radiation en weathering, but in different ways. Polycarbonate helmets are naturally UV-resistant, meaning they are less likely to discolor or become brittle from sunlight. Fiberglass helmets are often treated with a special coating to provide UV protection. This coating can wear off over time, requiring regular maintenance to maintain de protection.

Aging process of polycarbonate vs. fiberglass

The aging process of these materials differs significantly. Polycarbonate de tends to become slightly more flexible over time, which de can affect impact absorption. Fiberglass retains its structural integrity longer, but may develop small hairline cracks under extreme conditions.

Maintenance en care for optimal protection

Proper maintenance is essential for both types of helmets. Regular cleaning with mild soap en water helps remove dirt en sweat that can corrode de materials. For fiberglass helmets, it is important to regularly inspect de outer layer for minor damage. For polycarbonate helmets, it is recommended to keep them away from de extreme heat, as this can deform the material.

Regardless of the material, it is crucial to replace your helmet after an accident or after de recommended usage time by de manufacturer. This ensures that you are always optimally protected while riding.

Cost consideration

When choosing a helmet, it is important to consider not only de safety aspects, but also de cost. Let's take a look at de financial side of polycarbonate en fiberglass helmets at de .

Initial acquisition cost

Polycarbonate helmets are generally less expensive than their fiberglass counterparts. This is due to de lower production costs of polycarbonate. For novice riders or those on a limited budget, a polycarbonate helmet can be an attractive option without sacrificing safety.

Fiberglass helmets tend to be more expensive, but often offer more advanced features en a longer service life. They are often seen as an investment in comfort en durability.

Long-term cost-effectiveness

Although fiberglass helmets have a higher purchase price, they tend to last longer. They maintain their structural integrity better, which can result in lower replacement frequency. Polycarbonate helmets may require more frequent replacement, especially with heavy use.

Value for money

When weighing de costs, it is crucial to look at de total value. A more expensive fiberglass helmet may be more cost-effective in the long run because of its longer life en better protection. On de the other hand, polycarbonate helmets offer excellent protection for their price, making them a smart choice for many riders.

Remember that de best helmet is always the one that fits your specific needs en budget, without compromising on safety. Whether you choose polycarbonate or fiberglass, make sure your helmet meets de applicable safety standards.

Regulatory en certifications

When it comes to de safety of motorcyclists, regulations en certifications play a crucial role. Let's look at de key aspects in this area for polycarbonate en fiberglass helmets.

European safety standards for motorcycle helmets

In Europe, all motorcycle helmets must comply with de ECE 22.05 or de newer ECE 22.06 standard. These standards set strict requirements for de performance of helmets at impact, penetration en other safety criteria. Both polycarbonate and fiberglass helmets can meet these standards provided they are properly designed en manufactured.

Performance in safety tests

Polycarbonate en fiberglass helmets perform differently in safety tests:

  • Polycarbonate helmets often score well on repeated impacts because of their flexibility.
  • Fiberglass helmets excel in severe, single-impact tests thanks to their superior energy absorption.

Importance of ECE mark

The ECE seal of approval is essential when choosing a helmet. This seal guarantees that de helmet meets de European safety standards. When de purchasing a new helmet, whether polycarbonate or fiberglass, it is crucial to check for de presence of this seal. This assures you of a helmet that meets de highest safety standards, regardless of the material.

De right choice

When choosing between a polycarbonate or fiberglass helmet, there are several factors to consider. It is important to consider your riding style en frequency of use. Frequent riders or those who often travel long distances may benefit from de lighter fiberglass helmets because of the increased comfort during extended use. On de other hand, occasional riders or urban motorcyclists may get more value from de durability en cost-effectiveness of polycarbonate helmets.

Driving style en frequency of use

Your riding style plays a crucial role in de choice. Sporty riders who reach higher speeds may benefit from de superior impact protection from fiberglass. For daily commuters who are more frequently exposed to minor impacts or falls, de flexibility of polycarbonate may be a better option.

Personalized fit en comfort

Ultimately, de best helmet is the one that fits your head shape perfectly en feels comfortable, regardless of the material. A well-fitting helmet not only improves de safety but also makes for a more enjoyable riding experience. Take de time to try on different models en watch for pressure points or loose spots.

When making your choice, consider visiting a specialized store where you can get expert advice en try out different options. That way you'll find de helmet that best suits your needs, whether polycarbonate or fiberglass.

Conclusion

After analyzing de advantages en disadvantages of polycarbonate en fiberglass helmets, we can draw some important conclusions:

  • Both materials provide excellent protection, but in different ways
  • Polycarbonate helmets are cost-effective en resistant to light impacts
  • Fiberglass helmets excel in energy absorption during heavy impacts en are lighter in weight
  • De choice depends on personal driving style, budget en comfort preferences
  • Regardless of the material, a good fit en ECE certification is crucial for optimal safety

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Which helmet material is safest: Both materials are safe provided they meet de ECE standards. De choice depends on your specific needs en riding style.
  • How long does a motorcycle helmet last? On average 5-7 years, depending on use en maintenance. Replace de helmet immediately after an accident.
  • Are more expensive helmets always better? Not necessarily. Quality en safety depend more on de fit en certification than on de price.
  • Can I repair a fiberglass helmet myself? No, always leave repairs to professionals or replace de helmet if damaged.
  • How do I best maintain my helmet? Clean regularly with mild soap en water, avoid chemicals en extreme temperatures.
  • Is a heavier helmet safer? Not necessarily. A lighter helmet may be more comfortable during long rides, which indirectly de promotes safety.
  • How do I know if my helmet is still safe? Check regularly for visible damage, fit en comfort. When in doubt, have de helmet inspected by an expert.

For those still unsure between polycarbonate en fiberglass, Vespucci offers a wide selection of both materials. Their expert consultants can help you make de the right choice to suit your specific needs en budget.

Price Indication Vespa Sale

Price Indication Vespa Sale

Please note: De indicated prices are indications. For a final valuation, we personally assess de Vespa.
Show Results

Filter

Type

Type
  • Integral (143)
  • System (108)
  • Jet (44)
  • Flip up (14)
  • Offroad (8)
  • Bicycle helmet (6)

Brand

Brand
  • Scorpion (156)
  • HJC (72)
  • ROOF (65)
  • Shark (65)
  • AGV (41)
  • Vespa (33)

Helmet material

Helmet material
  • Polycarbonate (158)
  • Fiberglass/Fiber Mix (125)
  • Carbon (44)
  • Bamboo Fiber (1)

Included Visor(en)

Included Visor(en)
  • Bright (209)
  • Light Smoke (55)
  • Internal Smoke Visor (8)
  • Dark Smoke (5)
  • None (4)
  • Internal Bright (3)
  • Iridium Silver (3)
  • Iridium Blue (2)
  • Iridium Quartz (1)
  • Iridium Red (1)
  • Photomatic Iridium Red ( 1)

Inspection

Inspection
  • ECE 22-06 (284)
  • ECE 22-05 (24)
  • EN1078 (3)
  • EN-1078 & CPSC (2)
  • NTA 8776 (1)
  • NTA-8776, EN-1078 & CPSC (1)

Number in package

Number in package
  • 1 system (18)
  • 2 systems (5)

Speed

Speed
  • 45 km/h (20)
  • 25 km/h (13)
  • 9610 (1)

Brand Speakers

Brand Speakers
  • Harman Kardon (7)
  • JBL (7)
  • Sena (4)
  • Cardo (2)
  • Cardo HD (1)
  • Vito (1)

Number of riders

Number of riders
  • 2 riders (9)
  • 4 riders (6)
  • 24 riders (4)
  • 15 riders (3)
  • 23 riders (1)

Maximum range

Maximum range
  • 8,000 meters ( 7)
  • 1200 meters ( 5)
  • 800 meters ( 3)
  • 400 meters ( 2)
  • 700 meters ( 2)
  • 2000 meters ( 1)
  • 450 meters ( 1)
  • 600 meters ( 1)

Battery life

Battery life
  • 13 hours (13)
  • 14 hours (3)
  • 10 hours (2)
  • 12 hours (2)
  • 16 hours (1)
  • 7 hours (1)

Voice control

Voice control
  • Yes (21)

Fits

Fits

Color

Color
  • Matte Black (135)
  • Gray (90)
  • White (80)
  • Red (74)
  • Carbon (69)
  • Gloss Black (65)

Price

Price

UV Protection

UV Protection
  • Yes (117)

Anti-scratch coating

Anti-scratch coating
  • Yes (117)

Interchangeability

Interchangeability
  • Easy (66)
  • Average (48)
  • Tricky (9)

Emergency release system

Emergency release system
  • No (200)
  • Yes (104)

Pinlock included

Pinlock included
  • Yes (160)
  • No (143)

Pinlock prepared

Pinlock prepared
  • Yes (326)
  • No (99)

Heated

Heated
  • Yes (6)
  • No (4)

Lowest Price Guarantee

You've seen the same product cheaper elsewhere? No problem, but please note that de shipping of this product is free at Vespucci. We will provide you (if approved) with a discount code. Please note this does not apply retroactively. 

How do you determine your helmet size?

It is important to choose de correct size for optimal comfort en safety. Follow these simple steps:

  1. Place the tape measure just above your eyebrows en your ears, around the widest part of your head. This is usually 2-3 cm above your eyes.
  2. Pull the measuring tape tight, but not so tight that it becomes uncomfortable.
  3. Compare your head circumference in centimeters with our chart to determine your helmet size.

Size chart

No brand information available.